Also your insurance seems a little off saying they will only replace with parts that are OEM, as they should cover anything back to the way it was before an accident. My insurance people said if you have receipts for anything you do then they have to cover it for atleast that amount. When a friends dad backed into my left front and broke my aftermarket, clear corner dark tinted headlight the insurance was going to cover an aftermarket OEM style which was really cheap but once I told his company that they were aftermarket and I had receipts, they had to purchase me a new set to replace them, exactly as they were.
Either way good luck, and even if the insurance company themselves are hard to work with most bodyshops know how to work with the company and still make you happy. I could also be wrong but it looks the bumper just needs some fresh paint, and the rim may even be repairable though you will for sure need a new tire.
2003 Redfire & Black V6. Full suspension, 8.8 w/ 4.10s, tuned. 4.3L stroker + turbo capable of 550 hp soon
1992 5.0 Auto Hatchback...needs wiring, interior, ...basically everything
RIP: 2015 SHO PP, 12.87 @107 1/4 mile